Stage 05 · Lesson 12/15

Robotics Fundamentals · Lesson 12

Robot Platforms Compared

Est. 50–65 min

Why

Why the right platform matters more than the coolest one

Every robot shares the five layers from Lesson 1, but the body plan — the platform — changes everything: what it can reach, how it moves, how much it costs, how dangerous it is and how hard it is to control. OSHA groups industrial robots by structure (articulated, SCARA, Cartesian, parallel) and by how they work with people (collaborative and non-collaborative), and adds industrial mobile robots that navigate autonomously. This chapter compares platforms honestly, so you choose with numbers and reasons, not hype.

By the end you will be able to: describe the main platforms — articulated arms, SCARA, Cartesian gantries, parallel robots, wheeled mobile robots, drones, legged and humanoid robots; say what each is good and bad at, using DOF, workspace, payload and safety; explain collaborative vs non-collaborative robots and the four collaborative methods OSHA lists; read a real platform’s spec sheet (TurtleBot3 Burger); and build a weighted decision matrix to choose your own platform.

A small round two-wheeled TurtleBot3 Burger robot with stacked black plates, a circuit board and a round laser sensor on top
A TurtleBot3 Burger, a small teaching robot. Its official specs: 138 × 178 × 192 mm, about 1 kg, top speed 0.22 m/s, two XL430-W250 smart servos on the wheels, a Raspberry Pi 4 plus an OpenCR board, and a 360° laser distance sensor on top. A complete research platform that fits in a school bag.Photo: Kuscu0 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source: Wikimedia Commons · resized, converted to WebP

Concept

Robot platforms in plain words: same layers, different bodies

Think of vehicles in an Indian city. A cycle, an auto-rickshaw, a tempo, a bus and a metro all move people and goods, but nobody uses a bus to deliver one parcel through a narrow galli, and nobody uses a cycle to move 60 passengers. Each vehicle is a *platform* designed for a job. Robots are the same: pick the platform for the job, not the other way round.

The platform family

Common robot platforms
PlatformTypical joints / motionStrengthsWeaknessesTypical jobs
Articulated armAt least 3 rotary joints (often 6)Large, flexible workspace; any orientation with 6 DOFTorque at full reach; complex kinematicsWelding, painting, handling, your 6DOF arm
SCARARRPR, 4 DOFFast, compliant in XY, rigid in ZPlanar work onlyAssembly, pick-and-place
Cartesian / gantryPPPSimple maths, rigid, heavy loadsFrame bigger than its workspace3D printing, plotting, CNC, palletising
Parallel (delta, Stewart)Several chains to one toolVery fast, stiffSmall workspaceHigh-speed picking, motion simulators
Wheeled mobile robotTwo driven wheels (diff-drive) or moreCheap, efficient on flat floorsStairs and rough groundDelivery, warehouses, cleaning, research
Drone (multirotor)Four or more propellersGoes anywhere in the airShort flight time, payload, safetyInspection, mapping, photography
Legged / humanoidMany joints per legRough terrain, human spacesExpensive, complex, balance and powerResearch, demonstrations

OSHA’s own descriptions match: articulated robots have at least three rotary joints; SCARA robots have two parallel rotary joints that are compliant in the XY plane and rigid in Z, typically used in assembly; Cartesian (linear, XYZ or gantry) robots have a rigid structure for heavy loads, plotting and 3D printing; and parallel robots connect several separately controlled chains to one tool for very high-speed pick and place.

Collaborative or not?

OSHA separates non-collaborative applications (robots behind traditional machine safeguarding, such as fences) from collaborative applications designed for direct interaction with workers. A collaborative application uses one or more of four methods:

Collaborative methods described by OSHA
MethodIdea
Speed and separation monitoring (SSM)Sensors detect a person; the robot slows or stops, and resumes when the area is clear
Hand-guided controls (HGC)A worker directly guides the robot’s motion, and the robot does the heavy lifting
Power and force limiting (PFL)Contact is permitted because forces are limited — by inherently safe design (low payload or speed) or by sensors and safety logic
Safety-rated monitored stop (SMS)Used with the others: the robot holds still, powered, while a person is in the space
A slim silver-and-blue collaborative robot arm mounted on a small trolley with a touchscreen pendant
A UR5 collaborative robot on a mobile stand. Cobots like this are designed for applications where people work nearby — but OSHA is clear that the *application* must be collaborative (risk-assessed, with SSM, HGC, PFL or SMS), not just the arm.Photo: GrowSkills Robotics · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source: Wikimedia Commons · resized, converted to WebP

Choosing with a decision matrix

score = Σ (weightᵢ × ratingᵢ) ÷ Σ weightᵢ

  • List your criteria (cost, safety on a desk, learning value, fit with your next project, build time), give each a weight, rate each platform 1–5 on each, and compute. The numbers are your judgement — the matrix just makes the judgement visible and arguable.

Visual

Visualise it: compare platforms side by side

Flip through the platform cards. For each one, find its **DOF**, its **workspace shape**, a job it is great at and one it is bad at.

Interactive · Robot platform cards

Deeper than Stage 0 type names — pick a platform and weigh strengths vs costs before Stage 6.

Manipulator / arm

Fixed base, high dexterity in a workcell.

Strengths

  • +Precise tool poses
  • +Repeatable pick/place
  • +Clear kinematics story

Costs / risks

  • −Limited workspace
  • −Power & payload care
  • −Singularities / collisions

Bridge · Direct prep for Stage 6 6DOF arm.

Code lab

Code lab: a weighted decision matrix

The script rates five platforms on five criteria (the ratings are an example judgement — edit them), ranks them with your weights, ranks them again with weights for someone not planning the 6DOF arm, and prints real reference numbers for the TurtleBot3 Burger. Run it with python3 platform_matrix.py.

platform_matrix.py · Python
"""platform_matrix.py - a weighted decision matrix for your first robot platform.
Scores 1-5 are YOUR judgement (edit them). Weights say what matters to you."""

CRITERIA = {"cost": 3, "safety_on_desk": 3, "learning_value": 2, "fits_6dof_path": 2, "build_time": 1}
PLATFORMS = {
    "Desktop servo arm (4-6 DOF)": {"cost": 4, "safety_on_desk": 4, "learning_value": 5, "fits_6dof_path": 5, "build_time": 3},
    "Two-wheel diff-drive rover": {"cost": 5, "safety_on_desk": 4, "learning_value": 4, "fits_6dof_path": 2, "build_time": 4},
    "Cartesian gantry / pen plotter": {"cost": 3, "safety_on_desk": 4, "learning_value": 3, "fits_6dof_path": 3, "build_time": 3},
    "Quadcopter drone": {"cost": 2, "safety_on_desk": 1, "learning_value": 4, "fits_6dof_path": 1, "build_time": 2},
    "Small humanoid / biped": {"cost": 1, "safety_on_desk": 3, "learning_value": 4, "fits_6dof_path": 3, "build_time": 1},
}

def rank(weights):
    total_w = sum(weights.values())
    scored = {p: sum(s[c] * w for c, w in weights.items()) / total_w for p, s in PLATFORMS.items()}
    return sorted(scored.items(), key=lambda kv: -kv[1])

print("== Ranking with your weights ==", CRITERIA)
for i, (p, s) in enumerate(rank(CRITERIA), 1):
    print(f"{i}. {p:32s} {s:.2f} / 5")

alt = dict(CRITERIA, fits_6dof_path=0, learning_value=3)
print("\n== If you do not plan to build the 6DOF arm ==", alt)
for i, (p, s) in enumerate(rank(alt), 1):
    print(f"{i}. {p:32s} {s:.2f} / 5")

print("\n== Reference platform numbers (TurtleBot3 Burger, ROBOTIS e-manual) ==")
for k, v in {"max speed": "0.22 m/s", "max rotation": "2.84 rad/s", "payload": "15 kg", "weight": "1 kg", "computer": "Raspberry Pi 4 + OpenCR (Cortex-M7)", "wheel actuators": "2 x XL430-W250", "range sensor": "360 deg LDS-02"}.items():
    print(f"  {k:16s} {v}")

Output (run with python3 platform_matrix.py)

== Ranking with your weights == {'cost': 3, 'safety_on_desk': 3, 'learning_value': 2, 'fits_6dof_path': 2, 'build_time': 1}
1. Desktop servo arm (4-6 DOF)      4.27 / 5
2. Two-wheel diff-drive rover       3.91 / 5
3. Cartesian gantry / pen plotter   3.27 / 5
4. Small humanoid / biped           2.45 / 5
5. Quadcopter drone                 1.91 / 5

== If you do not plan to build the 6DOF arm == {'cost': 3, 'safety_on_desk': 3, 'learning_value': 3, 'fits_6dof_path': 0, 'build_time': 1}
1. Two-wheel diff-drive rover       4.30 / 5
2. Desktop servo arm (4-6 DOF)      4.20 / 5
3. Cartesian gantry / pen plotter   3.30 / 5
4. Small humanoid / biped           2.50 / 5
5. Quadcopter drone                 2.30 / 5

== Reference platform numbers (TurtleBot3 Burger, ROBOTIS e-manual) ==
  max speed        0.22 m/s
  max rotation     2.84 rad/s
  payload          15 kg
  weight           1 kg
  computer         Raspberry Pi 4 + OpenCR (Cortex-M7)
  wheel actuators  2 x XL430-W250
  range sensor     360 deg LDS-02

Try it: drive a two-wheel robot by setting each wheel’s speed. Equal speeds go straight; different speeds turn — the simplest mobile platform to control.

Interactive · Differential-drive steering

start ● · path for 6 s

Motion

Curving left

Forward speed v

15.0 cm/s

Turn rate ω

0.667 rad/s

Turn radius R

22.5 cm

Like a tank or many robot vacuums: no steering wheel, just two motors. Speeds in cm/s; ω in rad/s (positive = turning left / anticlockwise). Ideal model: no wheel slip.

Real world

Platforms at work

  • Warehouses: tugger AGVs and mobile robots move goods; OSHA notes industrial mobile robots navigate autonomously and avoid obstacles.
  • Factories: articulated arms weld and handle, SCARA robots assemble, gantries palletise.
  • Labs and classrooms: wheeled research platforms like the TurtleBot3; desktop arms.
  • Inspection and mapping: drones photograph roofs, towers and fields.
  • Research and science centres: humanoids and legged robots explore human-like motion.
A white DJI Phantom quadcopter drone with four propellers hovering outdoors in front of trees and a van
A DJI Phantom 3 Advanced quadcopter. Drones go anywhere in the air, but flight time, payload and safety near people limit them — which is why they score low for a first desk robot even though they are brilliant platforms.Photo: Jacek Halicki · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source: Wikimedia Commons · resized, converted to WebP
A blue-and-white humanoid robot standing on a display platform at a science centre
A humanoid robot at Science Square Tsukuba. Humanoids fit human spaces and excite everyone, but every extra joint is another motor to power, calibrate and control.Photo: Syced · CC0 1.0 · Source: Wikimedia Commons · resized, converted to WebP
A low automated guided vehicle towing a line of trailers loaded with goods through a large warehouse
A tugger AGV (Egemin) towing trailers in a warehouse. A wheeled platform with sensors and a simple job — move loads along routes — done all day, every day.Photo: AGVExpertJS · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Source: Wikimedia Commons · resized, converted to WebP

Bench build

Bench build: a platform audit

Pick one real robot or robotic toy you can handle (a robot vacuum, a toy car, an RC drone with props removed, a kit arm, your Stage 4 bench) and audit it like an engineer.

  1. Classify

    Which platform family is it? Write its joint string (Lesson 3) or wheel layout.

  2. Measure

    Weigh it, measure its size, time a battery charge if you can, and measure top speed with a ruler and a phone stopwatch.

  3. Find the layers

    List its actuators, sensors, controller and safety features.

  4. Workspace

    Where can it go or reach? Sketch it (a ring for an arm, a floor area for a rover).

  5. Hazards

    What could hurt someone? Pinch points, props, wheels, hot parts, falling.

  6. Compare

    Put your measurements next to the TurtleBot3 Burger’s published specs. What is better, what is worse?

Debugging

Debugging platform choices

ProblemLikely causeBetter choice
Robot can’t reach the taskWrong workspace shapeArm for a shell around a point; gantry for a flat rectangle; rover to go to the task
Battery dies in minutesPlatform too power-hungry (drone, humanoid)Wheeled or fixed-base platform; bigger battery; tethered power for a desk arm
Project stalls at calibrationToo many joints for a first buildFewer DOF; add joints after the first version works
Robot is unsafe on a shared deskHigh speed or energy near peopleSlow, light platform; limits and e-stop (Lesson 13)
Can’t find help or partsRare platformChoose a common, documented platform (e.g. a ROS-supported rover or a standard servo arm)

Think

Think about it

Think

A school wants one robot platform for 40 students learning robotics for a year, with a budget for about ten robots, shared desks and no workshop. Arjun votes for humanoids (“students love them”). Meera votes for wheeled rovers. What questions would you ask, and what would you recommend?

Experiment

Try it in the lab: choose a platform with a decision matrix

Thirty minutes with the platform cards, the diff-drive lab and the decision-matrix script.

Experiment

Choose a platform with a decision matrix

You will need

  • Robot platform cards (below, runs in your browser)
  • Notebook
  • Optional: `platform_matrix.py`; a robot or toy to audit

Steps

  1. Go through the platform cards. For each, write DOF, workspace shape, one great job and one bad job.
  2. Run `platform_matrix.py` as it is. Then change the weights to match *your* priorities and run again.
  3. Change two ratings you disagree with. Does the winner change?
  4. In the diff-drive lab, drive a square. Write the wheel speeds you used for straight lines and for turns.
  5. Write a three-sentence recommendation for your own first platform, quoting your matrix score.

Interactive · Robot platform cards

Deeper than Stage 0 type names — pick a platform and weigh strengths vs costs before Stage 6.

Manipulator / arm

Fixed base, high dexterity in a workcell.

Strengths

  • +Precise tool poses
  • +Repeatable pick/place
  • +Clear kinematics story

Costs / risks

  • −Limited workspace
  • −Power & payload care
  • −Singularities / collisions

Bridge · Direct prep for Stage 6 6DOF arm.

There is no best robot — only the best robot for a job. Platforms differ in workspace, payload, safety, cost and complexity, and a weighted matrix makes your reasons visible.

Knowledge check

Check your understanding

Knowledge check

1. OSHA describes articulated robots as robots with…

2. A SCARA robot is compliant (flexible) in which direction?

3. Cartesian (gantry) robots are commonly used for…

4. A collaborative application, in OSHA’s sense, is designed for…

5. In power and force limiting (PFL), contact with a person is…

6. The TurtleBot3 Burger’s published maximum speed is…

7. Why do drones usually score low as a first desk robot?

8. In a weighted decision matrix, changing the weights…

9. Industrial mobile robots (IMRs), according to OSHA, …

Mini assignment

Hands-on assignment

Mini assignment

Platform recommendation report

Choose a robot platform for a real job you care about (your first build, a school club, a family business task) and justify it with a decision matrix, a spec comparison and a hazard list.

Deliverables

  • A one-paragraph job description: what the robot must do, where, how often and near whom.
  • Your edited `platform_matrix.py` with your own criteria, weights and ratings, and its output.
  • A spec comparison table of your top two platforms (size, mass, speed or reach, payload, run time, price) with sources.
  • A hazard list for the winner and how you would reduce each hazard.

Do this, step by step

  1. Write one paragraph describing the job: what the robot must do, where, how often and near whom.
  2. List four to six criteria (cost, payload, terrain, safety near people, run time…) and give each a weight.
  3. Rate at least three platforms on each criterion in platform_matrix.py, run it and read the ranking.
  4. Make a spec table for your top two platforms (size, mass, speed or reach, payload, run time, price) with a source link for each number.
  5. Write a hazard list for the winner and one way to reduce each hazard.

Stuck? Hints, one at a time

NoteTry the task first. Read one hint, try again, and only then read the next one.
  1. Hint 1: Start from the job’s workspace: does the robot go to the task (mobile) or does the task come to it (fixed arm or gantry)?
  2. Hint 2: Pick 4–6 criteria. More than that and the matrix becomes noise.
  3. Hint 3: Use real numbers where you can (spec sheets) and say where you guessed.
  4. Hint 4: For hazards, think pinch, crush, cut, fall, fire (batteries) and electrical.

Challenges (pick by level)

  • 🟢 Easy: Match each platform to one job: SCARA, gantry, drone, rover, humanoid.
  • 🟢 Easy: From the TurtleBot3 spec, convert 2.84 rad/s into degrees per second.
  • 🟡 Medium: Add a sensitivity check to the script: change each weight by ±1 and report whether the winner changes.
  • 🟡 Medium: Write the five layers (Lesson 1) for a tugger AGV.
  • 🟠 Hard-ish: Compare a desktop arm and a gantry for sorting coloured blocks on a 30 × 30 cm area. Which has the better workspace fit, and why?
  • 🔴 Hard: Read OSHA’s collaborative section and design a small collaborative desk application using PFL by inherently safe design. List the speed and payload limits you would set.
  • ⚫ Expert: Build a mobile manipulator concept: a rover carrying a small arm. Compute the new payload budget, the effect on rover speed, and which collaborative method (if any) would apply.

Next step

Whatever platform you choose, it must be safe. In Lesson 13 — Safety, Limits & Operating Envelope you set joint limits, speed limits, keep-out zones, watchdogs and a real latched emergency stop.

Look back: Lesson 11: End Effectors & Tooling. Next: Lesson 13: Safety, Limits & Operating Envelope. Related: Stage 10 — ROS 2 and Stage 12 — Simulation.

Sources

  • OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV Chapter 4 — robot structures (articulated, SCARA, Cartesian, parallel); collaborative vs non-collaborative applications; SSM, HGC, PFL (inherently safe design or control means) and SMS; industrial mobile robots navigate autonomously and avoid obstacles.
  • ROBOTIS e-Manual: TurtleBot3 Features — Burger specifications: 0.22 m/s, 2.84 rad/s, 15 kg payload, 138 × 178 × 192 mm, 1 kg, 2 h 30 min operating time, Raspberry Pi 4, OpenCR (Cortex-M7), XL430-W250, LDS-02.
  • Modern Robotics — K. M. Lynch & F. C. Park (preprint PDF) — open vs closed chains; Stewart platform as a parallel mechanism; workspace depends on structure.
  • Photos: Wikimedia Commons (credits under each image).

Self-attested for now — keep artifacts in your lab notebook.

Complete

Today's goal

0 of 1 done today

0-day streak
Daily goal:lessons, quizzes or assignments a day

Mark this lesson complete when you have worked the experiment, knowledge check, and assignment (even roughly).

Stuck somewhere?

Ask a doubt about this lesson

Saved with this lesson's id and your email so we can reply. Privacy · or email contact@aihubstation.in